I had many problems with the movie, but for this post I'm going to focus on one: its simplistic portrayal of love, and how it set feminism back 300 years. (Please keep in mind that I have never considered myself a feminist.)
One of my pet peeves with media is when men fall in love with women based solely on looks. Details such as character development, getting to know a person, and developing a real relationship are glossed over or entirely omitted. In real life, when two people share a physical but no emotional attraction, their relationship lasts at most for 3 or 4 awkward dates. (Just look at "Sex and the City" -- I am totally serious.) So why do books and movies repeatedly show a man going gaga for a pretty face? For each relationship in this movie, let's look at how well the man got to know the woman before falling in love.
- Keira Knightly and her husband's best friend. It is not known if they had a conversation.
- Hugh Grant and the servant. They had about 2 conversations. Most of their dialog was her saying "Your biscuits, sir".
- Alan Rickman and his secretary. They had brief one-sentence exchanges around the office.
- Colin Firth and his Portuguese maid. They had the most dialog before falling in love, but it was in languages the other didn't understand.
- The porn couple. They had the most fulfilling relationship.
- Keira Knightly and her husband's best friend. Their occupations are unknown.
- Hugh Grant and the servant. A prime minister falls in love with his servant.
- Alan Rickman and his secretary. A managing director falls in love with his secretary.
- Colin Firth and his Portuguese maid. A wealthy writer falls in love with his maid.
- The porn couple. Again, this is the least unflattering relationship -- their social status is approximately the same.
When one starts to look wistfully back at American romantic comedies because of their character development and strong females, you know you have a problem. Now, if you'll excuse me, there are some pillows that need fluffing.
1 comment:
Awesome post! I think this is the first thing that I would say I truly Laughed out Loud. However, I don't think there is anything wrong with these scenarios. A prime minister falling in love with his maid? I recently applied to a cleaning service at the White House. Channeling Monica Lewinksy.
Post a Comment